Does a Commission-Based Pay Structure Make Sense For Your Store?

The debate over commission-based models in retail is as old as the industry itself. Does it make sense for your business? Is it time to ditch hourly rates? The answer depends on various factors. Below, we break down seven essential considerations to help you decide whether a commission model is right for your retail store.

1. Assess Your Business Model

The first step is understanding your business type.

• High-Ticket or Specialized Products: A commission-based model might work if your products are expensive or require in-depth product knowledge. These sales often demand persuasion and expertise, which commissions can incentivize.
• Transactional Businesses: Stores with high traffic, lower-priced goods may benefit from sticking to an hourly pay structure.

2. Understand Your Customer Experience Goals

While commission can motivate employees to prioritize customer engagement, it can sometimes lead to overly aggressive sales tactics. This might deter customers from visiting or returning.

Case Study: In the 1990s, an Ann Taylor store with a commission-based model had top sellers who generated significant revenue. However, some customers avoided the store due to their aggressive behavior, ultimately hurting the business.

Striking the right balance is key. Does your team collaborate well, or do individual sales goals create unhealthy competition? Aim for the entire store’s success, not just individual achievements.

3. Evaluate Financial Feasibility

Is your sales volume steady enough to sustain commission payouts, even during slow periods? Compare commission costs to your current hourly wage expenses. While commissions can boost sales, they may also increase payroll costs. Collaborate with your finance team to analyze this tradeoff.

4. Analyze Employee Impact

Switching to commission affects employees differently:

• Pros: Motivated sellers may thrive and exceed sales expectations.
• Cons: Those who value income stability might find the model stressful and leave.

Additionally, top performers who fail to meet their earning goals may quickly jump ship, leading to high turnover.

5. Run a Pilot Program

Before committing to a full rollout, test the commission model for at least 90 days. Use this period to assess its impact on sales, employee satisfaction, and customer experience. Make adjustments based on the data collected.

6. Consider a Hybrid Model

A hybrid approach can blend stability with performance incentives. Some options include:

• Base Pay + Commission: Offers employees a safety net while rewarding performance.
• Team-Based Commission: Encourages collaboration by tying bonuses to collective store success.
• Bonus Structures: Provide periodic bonuses when the store achieves sales targets without altering hourly pay.

Work with your finance team to ensure the math aligns with your profitability goals.

7. Monitor Key Metrics

Continuously track performance indicators to evaluate the success of your commission model:

• Sales Per Associate
• Customer Satisfaction Scores
• Employee Turnover Rates
• Profit Margins
• Payroll Percent to Sales: Ideally, this should remain at or below 15%.

High payroll costs can hurt profitability, so stay vigilant about this metric as you assess the model’s effectiveness.

Final Thoughts

Deciding whether a commission-based model makes sense for your retail store isn’t straightforward. It requires thoughtful consideration of your business type, customer goals, employee impact, and financial feasibility. Testing and continuous monitoring are essential to make informed decisions.

Schedule a free strategy call and discuss how Running Great Stores can help!

If you found this guide helpful, share it with other retail professionals, and subscribe for more insights on Running Great Stores!